I think it’s you, not me…
By Robert McCulloch
If you work in advertising or production, you’ve probably had this conversation more times than you care to remember.
How the hell are we supposed to deliver this level of creative ambition with this budget and this timeline?
More platforms. More deliverables. Less time. And budgets that haven’t exactly kept up.
We’ve become very good at talking about the problem. What I can’t quite understand is why we’re still so reluctant to change the way we work.
Because almost everything about our industry has changed. Except, it seems, the way we award production.
A brief goes out. Directors pitch. A treatment gets chosen and, almost by default, so does the production company attached to that director.
The next job comes along and we do it all again. Different people, different relationships, different processes. Much of what was learned on the previous production disappears with the team that made it.
And everyone starts again.
So why not change the order?
Choose the production partner first.
Find a partner who understands your business, your standards, your budgets and how you like to work. Then find the best director and specialists for each brief together.
It’s hardly a revolutionary idea.
Ten years ago, it might have been more difficult. Directors were tied far more exclusively to production companies and territories. But that world has changed dramatically.

Outside of a handful of top-tier directors, genuine exclusivity is increasingly rare. Most directors aren’t on monthly retainers, and where those exclusive relationships do exist, there’s often an ownership stake or some other commercial arrangement involved.
Talent now moves far more freely between companies, countries and disciplines. There are still a few peculiarities, of course. Take loan-out fees, for example. When a director works through another production company, there’s often a fee involved, frequently absorbed by the director rather than passed on to the agency or client, simply to remain competitive.
So the flexibility to work with different talent already exists. We just haven’t necessarily adapted the model around it.
Which brings me back to the question. Why are we still behaving as though choosing a director means choosing an entirely new production company every time?
The point isn’t to limit creative choice. Quite the opposite.
The production partner becomes the constant. The creative team changes according to the work.
But does changing the order actually solve anything?
Well, it doesn’t magically create more money or more time. But I think there are some fairly obvious advantages.
Firstly, continuity. Every new production relationship comes with a learning curve. Understanding the client, the agency, the expectations, the processes and the inevitable quirks. That takes time, and time costs money.
A long-term production partner retains that knowledge. Each job builds on the last rather than starting from scratch.
Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, it brings production experience into the creative decision much earlier.
Not every job sits in the same place. Some have substantial budgets and the time to explore ambitious creative ideas. Others need to achieve just as much with far less money and considerably tighter timelines.
Understanding where a job sits creatively, economically and practically is critical to deciding who should make it.
Different directors bring different strengths. Some thrive on complex, high-end productions. Others are incredibly resourceful, decisive and capable of delivering exceptional work within tight constraints. Neither is necessarily better, but they require different skills beyond simply having a strong creative vision.
Having an experienced production partner involved early means those realities can inform the choice of director, rather than becoming problems to solve once that choice has already been made.
It’s not about compromising the creative. It’s about protecting it.
And thirdly, there’s the accumulated knowledge. What worked, what didn’t, where money was wasted, where time was saved, who delivered brilliantly. That experience becomes increasingly valuable with every project, and the next director benefits from it too.
We’ve had this conversation with agencies over the years, and what’s interesting is that most people agree. Some get genuinely excited about the idea.
Then the meeting ends and the next job gets awarded in exactly the same way.
I get it. The existing process is familiar. Everyone’s busy. There’s always another deadline and another job to get out the door.
But surely that’s part of the problem?
We’re trying to find efficiencies inside a system that perhaps needs rethinking in the first place.
I’m not suggesting this is the answer to every production challenge. There will always be projects where choosing a particular director first makes perfect sense. And good reasons to work with different production companies.
But when brands are producing more content, more frequently, across more platforms, surely there’s a compelling argument for building longer-term production relationships rather than starting from scratch every time.
We’ve changed how we create, distribute and consume content.
Perhaps it’s time we reconsidered how we produce it.
The creative ambition doesn’t have to change.
The order does.